Woman’s In-Laws Expect Her to Host Both Thanksgiving and Christmas Dinners Despite Going Through Difficult Postpartum Period

Advertisement
  • 01
    r/Amlthe u/Cautious_Quote 6913 • 1d AITA for not telling my husband we should still host Thanksgiving and Christmas this year?
  • 02
    My husband (27m) and I (26f) had our first child in June. We had previously been very close to his family but since our son's arrival things have strained tremendously. My ILs have a tradition where each generation alternates the grandparents names for first and middle names. My husband's middle name is his grandfather's first name. FIL has his grandfather's first name as a first name. Our son was meant to have FILs name as his first name. Or this is what my ILs hoped for. But my husband and I w
  • 03
    name because of the tradition and wanted to avoid it for our son too. We ended up choosing a name they didn't like or approve of which made the whole thing more tense. They spent weeks trying to convince us to change it and my husband shielded me from hearing most of it, but I was still aware he was experiencing their attempts on a pretty much daily basis. He ended up blocking them from our phones for a temporary period. He calmed down and told them they were not to bring it up again and he was
  • 04
    My PP period has been rough. Even now I'm still not doing as good as I had hoped to be. But the first three months PP were three of the worst months of my life, and I feel so guilty saying that because I love my son more than I love anyone or anything. But I was miserable those first three months and I'm still not "there" yet. It's improving.
  • 05
    My ILs quietened down at first but the first time we saw them again after everything, they brought it up again and said they wanted us both to hear them express why they were so upset. My husband told them no. Then his family mentioned Thanksgiving and Christmas. We were supposed to host and they brought up how awkward it would be with tension lingering. My husband said they're right so we won't host or join them this year because it wouldn't be good for me or our son.
  • 06
    His family begged me twice since then to tell my husband we should still do it. They brought up how I had offered and had been looking forward to it. And I was. But not so much now. I'm worried they will turn it into two miserable experiences when I'm still not at my best. My son needs a mom who isn't a shell of herself. I don't want it to turn into family holidays where everyone talks about how much they hate the name and how we made the wrong choice. But a part of me feels guilty for my stance
  • 07
    NTA. diminishingpatience. 1d Judge, Jury, and Excretioner [359] We were supposed to host and they brought up how awkward it would be with tension lingering. The tension that they created. They need to shut up now. Reply 2.4k
  • 08
    Neon Owl_333 • 23h What is their plan for the awkwardness? Do they think harassing them more about their baby's name is going to solve the holiday awkwardness? 126
  • 09
    Acceptable-Soup5156 • 22h I read this as it would be awkward to come to your house with tension lingering, so fix his name before we come for the holidays so everything will be better.. it sounded like a threat rather than an actual attempt to reconcile.. maybe I'm just interpreting it wrong. 105
  • 10
    bythebrook88 · 1d Aficionado [10] Then his family mentioned Thanksgiving and Christmas. We were supposed to host You are struggling with an infant. Anybody who cares about you would not want to add any more stress by making you host. Either they host, or there's no family gathering. Reply 543
  • 11
    Right? Jodenaje • 21h My mind is blown at having the family with the new baby host either of those holidays anyhow. And not just one, but both Thanksgiving AND Christmas. That's a lot to expect of anyone in the same year, much less parents of an infant! ← 190
  • 12
    Professor Yaffle1 • 19h Colo-rectal Surgeon [45] Well, sometimes hosting is easier than packing up a baby and going somewhere, but it does depend hugely on the family/guests ☆ ↑ 39 ⇓
  • 13
    Inevitable-Place9950 18h Partassipant [4] Yeah, if the family brings parts of the dinner and takes on cooking and baby care so the parents can rest, that could definitely be easier. But not with PPD and not with these grandparents. ... 41
  • 14
    ptrst • 17h Yeah, we've hosted everything since our son was born (he's 10 now). It's way easier to cook Thanksgiving dinner than it is to supervise my child in an unfamiliar environment! When he was a baby, he could be in his pack-and-play; now that he's older, he just plays on his Switch. And I don't have to worry about him getting too curious or bored and breaking someone's fragile decor items they helpfully keep at little kid eye level. ... 10 ⇓
  • 15
    Rugbylady1982 • 23h NTA they will ruin your first Christmas and Thanksgiving let them do it. about the name, please don't Reply 99
  • 16
    Foamy-lizard • 16h You will never get that time back OP. Don't ruin a holiday you'll never get back w your baby. Best advice my brother ever gave me when our baby was born "put your foot down sooner than later, you'll never get this time back again - be an for the sake of your peace" ← 27 д
  • 17
    Automatic_Value7555 17h But a part of me feels guilty for my stance because we don't have another extended family and we got along so good before this. I'm going to guess that up until your son was named you did everything on their terms. Now that you've expressed your own opinions and made adult choices the in-laws are throwing a months long tantrum. You are 100% correct that your son and your mental health comes before anything your in-laws might want. I'm so happy to read your husband put his
  • 18
    NTA. mphflame 21h Partassipant [2] As a grandparent, they need to get over their manipulative, controlling and drop it. child already has a name, and that is that. The need to deal w it. Your Do not feel guilty about not hosting. You had no clue that this would be your reality right now. You do not need to take on dealing w a bunch of whiny children posing as adults on top of cleaning and cooking for all. Take the time to breathe and get in your rhythm w your baby and your hubby. understand, tou
  • 19
    Severe-Hope-9151. 1d Aficionado [12] NTA, at all. You could try a test before Thanksgiving by having some of the family over for dinner. Make sure they know topics not to be discussed and see if they can abide. This would give you an idea of how Thanksgiving would go without doing all the work required for that big meal. ← ☑ Reply 4 ♡
  • 20
    Jynx-Online • 21h Your husband sounds amazingly supportive and like a very good man. Your ILs sound insufferable. NTA to you or your hubby. Wish you both the very best. Enjoy a peaceful first year. Best decision I ever made with my son was to step back from large familiy gatherings and have smaller, less stressful events instead. Good luck to you both. Reply Д 4
  • 21
    Scenarioing 21h Professor Emeritass [81] "They brought up how I had offered and had been looking forward to it." ---So they could pressure you more while you are a captive audience. Please don't let them abuse you further. There is nothing to feel guilty about. Also, they will try to make your son take on the name as a used nickname. Do not let them think they can do this or have contact if they will. ← Reply зд 3 ⇓
  • 22
    Jacintaleishman • 21h Partassipant [1] Baby's first Thanksgiving and Christmas with just mum and Dad? Absolutely perfect. ... Reply ↑ 3 ↓ зд

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article